Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Brooklyn

  • Gallery Slide 1
    Slide 1 of 3
  • Gallery Slide 2
    Slide 2 of 3
  • Gallery Slide 3
    Slide 3 of 3

    • Hours & Location

    505 Myrtle Avenue,
    Brooklyn, NY 11205
    (646) 494-3630
    info@peteespie.com

    Open Daily 9AM - 10PM

    Get Directions

    Menus

    Info

    This menu reflects what we have available in each of our locations on a daily basis. While we do have most things available at any given time, we do run out of things occasionally. We bake fresh twice a day in small batches. We also source fresh ingredients and sometimes there can be unpredictable shortages from our farmers. 

    If there's something you know you absolutely want it's best to preorder. 

    You can pre-order for same day pickup or delivery here.

    Or if you're planning ahead you can place an order here.

    Additionally you can order by texting us at 212-966-2526 or emailing us at orders@peteespie.com

    We source our produce from local farms such as Samascott Orchards, Phillips Farms, Cahoon Farms and add just enough sugar and spices to enhance their natural flavor.

    Fruit Pies

    6/Slice | 35/whole
    • Hudson Valley Apple Pie

      Hudson Valley Apple Pie

      Our apple pies feature individual varieties of apples sourced from local orchards. New York State grows more apple varieties than any other, and our apple pies are a celebration of classic New York and heirloom varietals.

    • Hudson Valley Apple Crumb

      Our apple pie with a buttery crumb topping made with brown sugar, cornmeal, and pecans.

    • NY Sour Cherry

    • NY Sour Cherry Crumb

    • Wild Blueberry

    • Wild Blueberry Crumb

    Chess pie is a classic dish based on some of our favorite ingredients: butter, eggs, buttermilk, and sugar.

    Chess Pies

    6/Slice | 35/whole

    • Black Bottom Almond Chess

      A rich, decadent stunner flavored with amaretto, topped with toasted almonds and has a bottom layer of chocolate ganache.

    • Salty Chocolate Chess

      A crowd favorite! A classic chess pie flavored with sea salt, bittersweet chocolate, and cocoa.

    Nut Pies

    6/Slice | 35/whole

    • Brown Butter Honey Pecan

    • Maple Whiskey Walnut

    Custard Pies

    6/Slice | 35/whole

    • Coconut Custard

    • Farm Fresh Pumpkin

    • Sweet Potato

    Ice Box Pies

    6.75/Slice | 40/whole

    • Banana Cream

    • Lavish Chocolate Cream

    • Key Lime Meringue

    • Nesselrode

    Heritage Chicken Pot Pie

    Chili Garlic Beef Shank

    Cheese and Onion


    drawing of an apple

    ORDER PIE NOW!

    Also find us at:

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!
    Privacy Policy